Ronald Neame's final film is a limp affair. Victor Banerjee stars as an Indian immigrant who masquerades as a doctor, initially to get his leg over Amanda Donohoe. Banerjee is an appealing actor and talent lines the supporting ranks (Anna Massey, Geraldine McEwan, Trevor Howard, Denis Quilley) but the script is just a succession of tepid, sometimes tasteless, encounters which linger around sitcom level. The appearance of Richard Wilson and Warren Mitchell emphasises this dimension, as does the awful music from Ken Howard.I know the 80s were a different time, and Alec Guinness had played an Indian in Banerjee's international breakthrough A Passage to India, but it is awfully hard to stomach Mitchell's casting as a toilet attendant from the sub-continent. Hammering home the out-of-time vibe, Sinitta and Amanda Donohoe pop up to pop out of their costumes and disrobe titillatingly. None of the cast acts with distinction and Howard cuts a forlorn figure two years before his death.Directors from the golden mid-century era rarely adapted well to changing norms and often made vastly inferior work in the 70s and 80s. Neame adapted better than most and had the biggest hits of his career in the late 60s and early 70s but by 1986 the wind had gone out of his sails and Foreign Body remains an unworthy swan song.
This was a film that was on repeatedly on HBO / Cinemax in the late ‘80s and early ‘90s, and now is nowhere really to be found, except in the odd collection that is Amazon Prime. It’s an odd film, starring Victor Banerjee, who most Western audiences probably know from David Lean’s A Passage To India and also most recently Claire Denis’s High Life, and directed by the great Ronald Neame, an underrated British director who has such works as The Horse’s Mouth and Tunes Of Glory, both starring Alec Guinness and both available on the Criterion Collection. This, however, is not a high brow work. It’s almost a sex comedy, but not quite, more of a fish-out-of-water story that is quite antiquated; something along the line of a Bob Hope or Danny Kaye mistaken identity film, but with a little bit of ‘80s smut in it. There are some things that have clearly dated poorly, with perhaps most of all being the brown face performance of Warren Mitchell as a relative of Banerjee’s. But what hasn’t dated is Banerjee’s performance as the hapless yet sincere lead, and the fact it does include some palpable British racism Indians faced in Britain that the script doesn’t shy away from. In some alternate universe, this bid for Banerjee to be a British romantic comedy lead would have worked and been financially successful, and I think we all would have been better for it. In some ways, the pathos Banerjee summons for this role of the fool is very close to the best of Danny Kaye and Peter Sellers, and it’s a shame he didn’t get to pursue this more for the English-speaking market.
I had never seen this. I had always wanted to, but Tubi always gives you the forbidden treasure. Oh, it is terrible. I always knew it was. But I knew it was a special kind of terrible when it started. I saw a familiar face in a saree, 'Ohmigod, is that Sinitta done up to look unconvincingly Desi?'Looked up the credits, Christ it was. The man who brought us The Poseidon Adventure and The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie decided to make a 1970s British sex comedy with Indian jokes, in 1986. It's even set in 1975 (if only to have the gag - BMT - before Margaret Thatcher), but there's still very 80s bits that creep in like cars and a copy of IPC's My Guy magazine on the news rack. Warren Mitchell, second billed plays the QPR-supporting Indian cousin IQ Patel, but not only do they not even bother to brown him up, they just dress him like Alf Garnett. So he just looks like a slightly tanned (but maybe because Mitchell lived down under)Alf Garnett doing a dodgy accent. It's a pity because Victor Banerjee, who quit Anglophone films after this, is genuinely likeable. I remember Samira Ahmed saying this may be one of the worst British films she'd ever seen, and I kind of agree. Because why would you make this in 1986? When the British film industry was at its lowest ebb? I know 11 years was the same distance between American Graffiti's setting and release, but did anyone in 1986 really think, 'they should make another British sex comedy full of British stars slumming it?' Like this came out AFTER My Beautiful Laundrette. I know it's based on a novel, but it also feels a little bit like a sleazier version of Alan Bennett's Afternoon Off. Stratford Johns basically does his performance from George and Mildred, as the angry father of would-be love interest/Bottle Boys starlet Eve Ferret.And to make things even worse, the theme is by Lynda Hayes, the lady who sang the Jim'll Fix It theme.No longer ontubi