Not polished enough for me to declare this Hamaguchi's first "great film", but my god this is unbelievable for a student film(to be fair, it was the final one he made before graduation). While technically this is a little rough around the edges, with the digital photography not used to its benefit, and instead serving as a slight layer of detachment and coldness(arguably this is thematically relevant, but I felt it was a bit too disjointed/rough for it to be the intention), but everything else is pretty spectacular for a student film. Hamaguchi seems to prefer questions to answers, and this is the farthest I've seen him lean in that direction -- the scene on violence in the classroom, in particular, is some of Hamaguchi's best work, with each word carefully placed, continually clouding the already-muddied waters. He never allows his characters to fully work out their struggles with one another and internally, instead opting for a series of conversations, honest for the first time in their lives that shake them to their core. What feels consistent amongst the few I've seen from Hamaguchi is he never wastes time -- each conversation is essential to building his characters and ideas, and even though nothing is ever really worked out, it's given such nuance that it can't be worked out, at least not without years to ruminate on the consequences of the conversations he presents us with. I can't recall the last time I've been this excited about a filmmaker, and I've only seen three films from him so far, with two of them being directed as a student. Cannot wait to see where he goes next.













