This is a short film about what love is not: women as observed sex object; women catering to solipsistic male sex fantasies; tolerance for stalking and sexual harassment; the assumption that women yearn for any attention no matter how harmful. The film is worth watching for Kieslowski's skillful use of composition, lighting and color but it is a study of dated values that have been challenged by feminist ideology and gender politics.
"Are you seeing someone?"A Short Film About Love is also a short film about looking. Through it, Kieślowski engages in a dialogue between Love and Look in at least three different registers, and the result is a thoughtful and intriguing study of the way we look at the world and how these ways of looking inform our desire. It's no mere coincidence that both the posters for the film here on Letterboxd and over at IMDb feature the idea of someone's eyes being manipulated by love.Plot & CharacterFirst and most obviously, A Short Film About Love is about looking in the sense that it simply depicts the story of a man looking at a woman. The plot follows Tomek, a young man with a telescope and an obsession with looking at Magda, a woman who lives in an adjacent building. By looking at her regularly, he begins to fall in love with her, and he contrives ways for the two of them to meet. After a few rocky initial encounters, she invites him to her apartment. From this point the perspective of the story switches, and instead becomes about Magda looking at (or looking for) Tomek. I won't spoil anything for those who haven't seen it; for my purposes it's enough to know that it's a story about a man and a woman looking at each other. Language & World PlayThere are seemingly innumerable idioms and phrases which involve a relationship between gaze and desire, the two most common—and in this case most relevant—of which are "love at first sight" and "beauty is in the eye of the beholder". The film's script, particularly in the dialogue between Tomek and his godmother, constantly plays with these elements of language and the way they inform our ideas about love. When she asks him if he's "seeing someone", she's wondering whether he's dating someone or has a girlfriend, but this specific phrasing of the question leaves room for an ambiguous response. He is seeing someone, but that person doesn't know it. This equivocal phrasing highlights the importance of individual agency: Tomek is "seeing" Magda, but Magda isn't "seeing" Tomek (yet). This simple moment builds with the rest of the film to ask the question how we can love someone if they don't know about it. Can love be one-sided (like looking), or does it necessarily involve two parties?Cinematography & FramingAs in all of Kieślowski's films, there is an abundance of shots framed in such a way that the object being looked at is obstructed or distorted. When Tomek looks at Magda, his vision is not only augmented by the lenses he looks through, but also by the glass of both of their windows. Specifically, Magda's window has a spherical bulge in it which captures everything in the room, but in a distorted way. It's also significant that for the first half of the film, the camera shoots exclusively from Tomek's apartment into Magda's, and vice versa in the second. Through the construction of his images, Kieślowski shows us how we never see things as they are, that things are always influenced by the way we look at them.Quick Reading: Gaze, Desire, & FantasyAs with any good symbolism, these aspects of the film can be read any number of ways. For me, they explore the nature of fantasy and its relationship to desire and the gaze. By ritually looking at Magda, Tomek creates a fantasy image of her. This fantasy is enjoyable for him, but only at a distance: every time he gets close to Magda he becomes shy and withdrawn (in contrast to his intrusiveness when not facing her directly, e.g. stealing her mail). This tendency reaches its climax when Tomek enters Magda's apartment, an experience which proves too much for him. He has entered into his own fantasy frame and become the object of his own gaze, an intrinsically traumatic situation. He has come too close to encountering the truth of his desire, and retreats to the safety of his solitude.Krzysztof Kieślowski | Imgur Gallery400 reviews and 800 followers! Thank you everyone! Your encouragement keeps me dedicated to doing what I love!